Donate now

Privacy Policy

Protection of privacy is our first concern, and SQE does not sell or trade information provided by its subscribers or supporters. Your information is used to process donations and newsletter subscriptions, and to contact you about upcoming publications and events.

feed iconSubscribe to our Blog

Follow Us
Follow SQESocQualEd
on Twitter

Please note Downloads require you to have the Adobe Reader installed, you can get it here for free Adobe.com

 

 
 
Society for Quality Education

Zap that App in the Bud

May 27, 2011 by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) at 06:57 AM

Following up on Malkin’s post about “smart” phone use in the classroom, I came across this editorial written by an IT teacher.  What may surprise you is that he is against the idea because he knows that they will be a distraction and a time-waster:

“The simple truth is adolescent students overwhelmingly use personal electronic devices as entertainment and a distraction away from their duty to concentrate and learn in school.

I have never confiscated an iPhone or BlackBerry in the classroom and found the student was taking in a few lines of Chaucer or trying to get the latest news on what is happening in the world.

But I have certainly stumbled on material completely and utterly unrelated to what was going on in class.

I have caught students cheating on tests by trying to access classroom notes from their iPhone.”

and he points out:

“Whether it be at the local fast-food restaurant or clothing store, I have never seen any of my students text message, access their iPhone apps, or listen to music on their mp3 player while on duty at their part-time jobs. Could it be the “real world of business” also believes these devices are counterproductive and a distraction?”

I would add, when videos of teachers in various unflattering situations pop up on the web, you may see this policy zapped faster than you can text the words  “dumb and dumber”.

Comments

“I would add, when videos of teachers in various unflattering situations pop up on the web, you may see this policy zapped faster than you can text the words “dumb and dumber”.

Yes, I expressed this exact sentiment in a previous post.

When it’s a tool for learning it’s ok but when it becomes a tool for students/parents and community to sneak a peak at what’s really going on in the classroom look for the teacher unions to push those school boards AND their individual classroom teachers in the opposition direction and nix this idea quickly.

I see this as an exceptional opportunity for TDSB parents to get some things on the record too - like a photo or discussion at a parent-teacher interview or for a school council to access its parent community to canvass on an idea unpopular with the school board.

I have an idea for the TDSB.

How be the trustees elected to do their job…..do their job and stop passing the buck to classroom teachers and pony up some leadership in this area?

Posted by Chuck on 05/27 at 08:18 AM

Yes, it is an exceptional opportunity for parents to seek a peak on the classroom and what is going on. It was the reasons stated to me, why the lap top and other devices that have the capability of recording audio and video, that my youngest could not used her devices in that way, recording lessons. And it include, capturing lessons on the board, and apparently something to do with copyrights and privacy.

I also wonder how the privacy regulations are going to play into this. Since most school policies, taking pictures of other students by students, the student must seek permission of the other students, to allow them to take the picture. Sure is a pain, when their is gatherings of schools to display projects, sports activities, where taking pictures by everyone, is more or less common and entrench at these gatherings, that are on school property.

Posted by Nancy on 05/27 at 08:51 AM

good points re: the privacy issue.

Actually come to think about this, what’s protecting parents and students from teachers and school admin. from abusing the freelance use of the new technologies?

What about in emergency situations? Could a video or photo be used by police for instance in an accident or emergency situation? May be a positive app. there.

This opens up a whole new kettle of worms and does little to deliver actual education to students.

Same old typical school system, years behind the times when it comes to actually teaching the basics but way ahead of the game when it comes to new ways to divert our attention.

Posted by Chuck on 05/27 at 10:38 AM
Page 1 of 1 pages

Leave A Comment

Name:

Email (required but not displayed):

Emotions

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below: