Subscribe to our Blog
Could your daughter be a very happy car mechanic?
For ten years now, I’ve been fortunate to have been involved in a grade 8 technical skills challenge that involves a number of public schools in West Toronto. Teams of students are given a problem to solve that involves building a mechanism that (typically) moves objects from one location to another. This has been quite a learning and confirming experience for me and the other business people that get involved every year.
What’s been confirmed: Classroom teachers are no better or no worse than employees in many workplaces. Sure there are a few slackers, but the majority of the teachers are keen and truly grateful to have their students get hands-on experience applying concepts from the Science and Technology Curriculum. Also no surprise is that the principals that the better teachers work for are often superior. They show up on competition day to support their teacher and students. They’re both good leaders and managers.
What’s been learned: The trustees and senior administrators in our public school systems (and, not surprisingly our Faculties of Education) are clueless about the role of technology in our society and what our schools should be doing to prepare students for opportunities in technology careers. In the 90’s, school boards decided that the only kind of technology that mattered was computer technology. They shut down shops and sold off machinery at many middle schools. (Some principals saw the folly of this and stored their machinery out of sight knowing that it would be needed again one day.) Then in the late 90’s experienced machinists and other skilled technology workers began to retire in droves. Sure manufacturing plants have shut down, but many continue to thrive even in the face of fierce global competition and many are desperate for skilled technology workers.
A big part of the problem is that the people running our education system are clinging to some very outdated stereotypes. When they think “technology” education they see a student that can’t “cut it” in the academic stream building birdhouses in a carpentry shop. They should get out more and visit a modern manufacturing plant. People don’t stand at drill presses all day robotically pulling down levers to drill holes in blocks of metal any more. They use touch screens to program multiple machining centres. They use statistical techniques to analyze production processes looking for ways to reduce cycle times and scrap rates. The other part of the problem is that the education system moves so slowly in response to developments in technology. While some public education apologists claim that our public schools can accommodate different approaches, the misguided and lethargic actions of the public systems relative to technology education provide yet another strong argument for school choice.
Finally, in a spirit of fairness, I have to point out that the misconceptions about technology are not exclusive to our school systems—the media and parents are just as clued out. A number of teachers have recounted stories to me of students of theirs who had an obvious aptitude and love for hands-on work but were being blocked by their parents from pursuing a career in that direction. As one teacher lamented, “I had one girl that wanted to be a car mechanic and she would have made a great mechanic. But there was no way that her parents would let that happen.” Just what the world needs: another surly physician or unhappy lawyer.
I do agree with you, but there is another side that should be pointed out. My child, is being force to take wood shop, where the use of power tools and her two left hands are a recipe for disaster. Even at home, I still do not allow her to mow the lawn, for fear of her cutting off one or both of her feet. The funny part, is that the use of hand tools are not permitted, and where I have found that she does a much better job, building a bird house or a frame using hand tools. Cooking class and other related skills are now coming back to the schools, but I question cooking or sewing classes, where learning how to cook a box of kraft dinner is a requirement but not the recipe from scratch or learning how to sew, by jumping into complicated projects, without learning the basics of sewing by needle and thread. My child hates the classes where in cooking class, she is not allow to show her skills in cooking and baking from scratch and in wood shop, her skills are questionable, except in the area of planning and formulating the blueprint. It is there only, that the other kids fight over her as to what group she will join, and not her inability to saw straight on a line and of course her two left hands.